Criminal Creepypasta: Girls Stabbing for Slenderman

Criminal Creepypasta: Girls Stabbing for Slenderman


What began as a story of an adolescent found stabbed and her two friends gone missing quickly turned into one of the most bizarre attempted murder cases of recent years. When 12-year-olds Morgan Geyser and Anissa Weier were found at a furniture store in Waukesha, Wisconsin, across town from the sidewalk near Rivera Drive and Big Bend Road where their friend was found stabbed 19 times on her arms, torso, and legs. She identified Morgan and Anissa as her attackers, and the girls were taken into custody where they had a truly bizarre tale to tell.

It was all for Slenderman.

Anissa first learned about Slenderman on Creepypasta, a website primarily dedicated to internet urban legends and horror fiction, where she discovered that he was “the leader of Creepypasta”. (If you’re confused by that statement, join the club.) In the chain of command, beneath Slenderman is killers, then “proxies”. To become a proxy and “show your devotion to Slenderman”, someone must commit murder. They planned to murder their friend then pay a visit to Slenderman, who lives in “a mansion in Nicolet National Forest“, and become his proxies. Anissa explained to police that she wanted to “prove the skeptics wrong” and show that Slenderman is real.

Anissa Weier in police custody.

Anissa Weier in police custody.

After school on May 30th, Morgan and Anissa packed and met up with their friend/victim and headed off to Skateland until 9:30PM when they returned to Morgan’s home for an impromptu sleepover party. The plan was to kill the girl while she was sleeping around 2 AM, but for some unknown reason they decided against it. Instead, the following day, all three girls went to Davids Park In the park bathroom, Morgan handed Anissa a knife she’d grabbed before leaving home. Anissa said she couldn’t do it and had a breakdown. The trio decided to play hide and seek then, during which Morgan tackled the victim and stabbed her repeatedly. They fled on foot to Walmart while their victim crawled for her life to Big Bend Road.

Morgan Geyser led by police to her hearing.

Morgan Geyser led by police to her hearing.

While neither Morgan or Anissa felt remorse for what they did, they believed if they hadn’t done it that “he” would’ve killed their families (though Morgan said she didn’t know who “he” was). Upon learning the full story of the crime, Waukesha Police Chief Russell Jack told reporters, “Both suspects had a fascination with a fictitious character that often posted to a website that is a collection of small stories about death and horror. Parents should not be allowing their children to have unrestricted or unmonitored internet usage –whether it be on their computer on their smart phone on their PlayStation. All of those accesses to the outside world.”

By most accounts, the origin of the Slenderman internet legend (or creepypasta) is a 2009 contest entry to create a new fictional paranormal being on the SomethingAwful forums written by a “Victor Surge” showing a strange, faceless, unimaginably tall figure photoshopped into playground photos and claiming to be “One of two recovered photographs from the Stirling City Library blaze. Notable for being taken the day which fourteen children vanished and for what is referred to as “The Slender Man”.” Victor was inspired by Stephen King, Lovecraft, and Burroughs (as well as stories of Mothman and shadow people) in the creation of his creature. During a 2010 interview, Victor spoke about his creature’s widespread fame:

It was amazing to see people create their own little part of Slender Man in order to perpetuate his existence. I didn’t expect it to move beyond the SA forums. And when it did, I found it interesting to watch as sort of an accelerated version of an urban legend. It differs from the prior concept of the urban legend in that it is on the Internet, and this both helps and harms the status of the Slender Man as one. In my personal opinion, an urban legend requires an audience ignorant of the origin of the legend. It needs unverifiable third and forth hand (or more) accounts to perpetuate the myth. On the Internet, anyone is privy to its origins as evidenced by the very public SomethingAwful thread. But what is funny is that despite this, it still spread… by making something at the right place and time it can swell into an “Internet Urban Legend”.

One of Victor's doctored photos that started the Slender Man tale.

One of Victor’s doctored photos that started the Slender Man tale.

Though it’s admittedly pure fiction, Slenderman bears some resemblance to tall, slim malevolent beings from German and Native American folktales. Yet the “Paranormal Pastor” Robin Swope goes so far as to say that Slenderman is anything but fiction. He even wrote a book proclaiming that Slenderman is a real, demonic being. Undoubtedly, this only makes matters worse for young minds eager to believe anything they read on the internet as gospel truth.

The Creepypasta website issued a statement in regards to the stabbing, defending itself from some of the media’s wild accusations and ignorance on both the site and creepypasta as a whole:

I think that most of you will understand when I say it’s hard to justify pinning blame on an entire genre of writing. Unless you’re okay with blaming the world’s ills on Stephen King or H.P. Lovecraft, I don’t believe that it makes sense to say paranormal writing or an interest in the macabre should be blamed or even used as an indicator of a “sick” person (as a few emails have already felt the need to call both myself and all the authors here). The human race has long held and encouraged a fascination with things that go bump in the night… But if I may be so bold, I don’t believe that it’s the fault of Slenderman or horror writing in general that this happened… Disordered thinking can be terrifying and stressful and I just want to reiterate: if you think you might be suffering from any sort of mental health issue, know that you are not alone and that you can find help.


Join the Traveling Museum of the Paranormal and get awesome perks!


  1. Chris Savia

    06/03/2014 at 3:57 PM

    I believe I might’ve contributed a little bit to the Slender Man legend in New Jersey.

    My neighbors have little boys, and one night I brought up Slender Man. They weren’t acquainted since the parents are responsible, keeping ’em far away from the internet. They caught an earful about how Slender Man comes out of the woods, steals children who are never seen again, like a dark pied piper. At the end, I told ’em if they kept a pebble in their pants pocket, they’d be too heavy for Slender Man and therefore safe.

    Next day, I’m read the riot act because neither boy wanted to go to sleep out of fear of being taken away by Slender man.

    Stories get told on the playground, and those stories have legs, especially when embellished by young imaginations.

    • Ken Summers

      06/03/2014 at 4:08 PM

      Nice one!! I was expecting them to have pockets full of stones. LOL

      In almost every type of community, from towns and school to the internet, stories are created and spread like fire. I grew up with some local stories myself here. It’s interesting to watch how they get changed and added to as they make their way around to new people and new generations.

  2. jed

    06/03/2014 at 4:15 PM

    Of course Creepypasta would catch shit for this… people LOVE to toss blame around, don’t they? The way folks react to things like this really irritates me. And supposing that the Slenderman WERE real…how in the blue fuck would that justify committing murder?? Are kids these days getting dumber or is it just me?

  3. Saski

    06/04/2014 at 2:01 AM

    Surely at twelve years old you can tell the difference between creepy fiction and reality? At twelve I discovered Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Anne Rice and vampires, and I loved the idea of vampires and every macabre associated with then, but I never drank blood or bit any of my friends (except one time, but that had less to do with vampires and more to do with her having me in a headlock and we clearly weren’t getting along at that moment).

    And the Daily Mail’s take on it is just…ugh.

  4. Jenn

    06/04/2014 at 6:16 AM

    No because adults fall for things everyday. Case in point, I saw some links to slender man pics with the caption “scary”. Some believe the mermaid show on discovery channel was real. On and on.

    • Ken Summers

      06/04/2014 at 1:03 PM

      Gullibility and age are not intertwined. I blame a lot of it on the shift in the media from high-quality “let’s get to the bottom of this before printing” journalism to “get this out there before it’s all over Twitter” reporting (if that’s even an appropriate term for it).

  5. moses

    06/04/2014 at 12:35 PM

    Back when I was growing up we had a local monster in the woods called Greylag. It lived near an abandoned summer camp, and had ridiculous proportions for a woodland creature – three feet tall, seventeen foot wide, and mostly mouth and feet. No one ever asked how a monster that wide could run through dense forest, but all the kids believed it was there, including me!

    Children can and will believe anything. Sad thing is, the idea of running from or confronting monsters seems to have been replaced with the idea by some that they should be adored, or worshiped.

    • Ken Summers

      06/04/2014 at 12:59 PM

      Summer camps have been legend factories for as long as they’ve been around; I know of a few “creatures” associated with some camps in Ohio.

      Maybe all this paranormal television is changing the fear of the unknown into infatuation? Instead of running from things that go bump in the night, people are being told we should run right for it and bring a camera. Even so, there’s a big difference between those of us who thrill in the pursuit of the unknown and people who turn the unknown into an idol to worship on an altar.

  6. cygnus

    06/04/2014 at 1:22 PM

    I think these two girls recently watched Nightline or 20/20, one of those sunday night “news” shows that featured 2 girls who did this exact thing, but they killed their friend by stabbing her to death. I think the slender man reason is BS. These teens know whats real and not, cmon already.

    Here it is:

    This was just on tv within the past few weeks.

    • Ken Summers

      06/05/2014 at 3:11 AM

      Kids watching news programs? Now that’s pretty unbelievable!

  7. cygnus

    06/05/2014 at 3:08 PM

    It’s actually more unbelievable to think that these teens did not search high and low on the net for all things related to this slender man, and find out that it was a hoax. That’s unbelievable. That you think they couldn’t possibly have stumbled upon the show and saw it about two girls killing a classmate, That’s unbelievable. The show was about murder, why wouldn’t these two macabre girls watch it. Pretty closed minded Ken. Oh well. I don’t really even care.

    • Ken Summers

      06/05/2014 at 4:47 PM

      Guess you missed the humor intended there… then again, I also missed any part where I said they couldn’t have been copying off another recent murder or might have known Slenderman was pure fiction.

  8. cygnus

    06/05/2014 at 8:26 PM

    yeah. dry humor doesn’t come off too well via text. Well, the two sentences you typed do insinuate that you were saying they couldn’t have been copying a news show. From what I understand, sarcasm via text is usually accompanied by one of these 😉

    Anyway. I enjoy the site.

    • Ken Summers

      06/06/2014 at 8:50 AM

      If I included smileys every time I was sarcastic/dry, everything would be full of smileys. lol If something I say sounds like an ass, it’s usually sarcasm! I’m just so used to being sarcastic on here I don’t include the 😉 or 😛 much anymore.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login